Which Medium Can Do This?
Pairs get 10 technique cards and a mat with five columns: Page, Stage, Film, Audio and Multimedia. They place each card in the column of the medium that depends on that technique, then choose one card and write its effect on the audience.
The Cards
- A close-up fills the screen with one face while everything behind it is blurred
- Italic stage directions that a reader can stop and reread, such as "Enter Mariners wet"
- A spotlight picks out one actor on a dark stage in front of a live audience
- Actors shout from the aisles, right beside the audience's seats
- A story told only through voices, music and sound effects, with nothing to look at
- The reader taps a strange word, and a box opens with its meaning
- The camera looks up at a character from the floor, so he seems to tower over everyone
- A listener hears a door creak open somewhere behind the speaker and must picture the room
- The reader decides how fast to go and pictures every face for himself or herself
- Words, a moving drawing and a sound effect appear together when the reader swipes the screen
Procedure
- Pairs place all 10 cards; each column should end up with 2 cards
- They compare with another pair and settle any card placed differently by asking, "Could the other medium do this too?"
- Each pair writes one sentence naming the effect of one card on the audience, and one sentence comparing it with the experience of reading
- Answer key for the teacher: Page: the stage directions, the reader's own pace and pictures. Stage: the spotlight, the actors in the aisles. Film: the close-up with blur, the camera looking up. Audio: the story told only in sound, the creaking door. Multimedia: the tap-to-open meaning, the swipe that brings words, drawing and sound together
Discussion Questions
- Which card could fit in more than one column? What would have to change for it to move?
- Which medium gives the audience the most freedom to imagine, and which gives the least?
- Which card would you most want to use for Poe's black room, and why?
Modification
For students who need support, use three columns (Page, Stage, Film) and six cards: the stage directions, the reader's own pace, the spotlight, the actors in the aisles, the close-up and the camera looking up.