SVHS Website Header

My Cart

MS-ESS2-1NGSS*ScienceEarth and Space ScienceGrades 6-8

MS-ESS2-1: Modeling the Rock Cycle and the Energy That Drives It

In plain English: MS-ESS2-1 is the NGSS middle school performance expectation that asks students to develop a model of how Earth's materials cycle through melting, crystallization, weathering, deformation and sedimentation, and of the energy that drives the cycle: Earth's internal heat and energy from the sun, with gravity moving material. It is usually taught in grade 6, 7 or 8 Earth science.

Develop a model to describe the cycling of Earth's materials and the flow of energy that drives this process.

Clarification Statement: Emphasis is on the processes of melting, crystallization, weathering, deformation, and sedimentation, which act together to form minerals and rocks through the cycling of Earth's materials.

Assessment Boundary: Assessment does not include the identification and naming of minerals.

Next Generation Science Standards · Disciplinary Core Idea: Earth's Systems · Official standard

01

Lesson Plan

45-65 min

Overview

Students build and test a model of the rock cycle: the never-ending set of processes that change Earth's materials from one form of rock into another. There are three main kinds of rock. Igneous rock forms when magma (melted rock underground; called lava once it reaches the surface) cools and its crystals grow, a process called crystallization. Sedimentary rock forms when sediment (loose bits of rock, mud and shell) settles in layers, a process called deposition or sedimentation, and is then pressed together (compaction) and glued by minerals left behind by water (cementation). Metamorphic rock forms when heat and pressure deep underground bend, squeeze and change a rock without melting it, a process called deformation. Weathering breaks rock into sediment at the surface, and erosion carries that sediment away. Students trace the energy behind each step: Earth's internal heat drives melting, deformation and uplift, while energy from the sun drives the rain, ice and wind that weather and carry rock, and gravity pulls sediment downhill and presses buried layers together.

The NGSS Clarification Statement says: "Emphasis is on the processes of melting, crystallization, weathering, deformation, and sedimentation, which act together to form minerals and rocks through the cycling of Earth's materials." The Assessment Boundary says: "Assessment does not include the identification and naming of minerals." So this page names rocks (granite, basalt, sandstone, shale, slate) but never asks students to identify or name the minerals in them. Students do the practice of developing a model: they draw it, test it against rock samples and invented data, find its limits and revise it. Every data set is invented for teaching and labeled as invented. All hands-on work uses clay, rulers, hand lenses and rock samples; nothing is heated.

Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:

  • Develop a model that shows how melting, crystallization, weathering, deformation and sedimentation change Earth materials from one form to another
  • Identify the energy source for each process in the model: Earth's internal heat, or energy from the sun with gravity
  • Use texture evidence (crystal size, layers, bands) and invented data to place rock samples in the model
  • Explain that the rock cycle recycles the same matter and has no fixed order
  • Evaluate a model of the rock cycle, find its limits and revise it

Prior Knowledge Required

Students should already be comfortable with:

  • Weathering and erosion by water, ice, wind and plants 4-ESS2-1
  • Interactions among the geosphere, hydrosphere and atmosphere 5-ESS2-1
  • Melting and freezing as changes of state when thermal energy is added or removed
  • Finding a percent and reading a line graph

Lesson Procedure

45-65 minutes of class time across 5 phases.

  1. Warm-Up5-10 minutes

    Pass around a small cup of beach or play sand and a hand lens. Let students look at the grains for one minute before the question appears.

    Warm-Up Prompt

    "Each of these sand grains was once part of a solid rock. Where might this grain have been one million years ago, and where could it be one million years from now? Draw its journey as boxes and arrows."

    Collect a few drawings on the board. Many students draw a straight line that ends at the beach. Ask: "Does the journey stop there? What would it take to turn this sand back into solid rock?" Keep the drawings: students revise them at the end of the lesson.

  2. Direct Instruction15-20 minutes

    The model. Show Diagram 1. Each box is a form of Earth material, and each arrow is a process that changes one form into another. Matter is not made or used up: the same material is recycled again and again. Then add the energy. Earth's internal heat comes from heat left over from Earth's formation and from radioactive elements (atoms that slowly break apart and give off energy) inside the planet. It melts rock, drives deformation and pushes up mountains. Energy from the sun heats air and water, which drives wind, rain, snow and ice. Those move and break rock at the surface. Gravity pulls loose sediment downhill and makes it settle, and the weight of the layers above presses buried sediment together. Use Diagram 2 to show that rock gets hotter with depth, which is why melting and deformation happen deep underground.

    • Igneous rock to sedimentary rock

      Granite (an igneous rock with large crystals) is exposed on a mountain. Rain, freezing water and plant roots break it into sand grains, and a river carries the grains to a lake, where they settle in layers and are later buried.

      Result: Granite (weathering, erosion) → sand (deposition, compaction, cementation) → sandstone. Energy: the sun drives the rain and ice; gravity moves the grains downhill and the weight of later layers presses them together.

    • Compaction of buried mud

      Invented data: a 12 m thick layer of wet mud on a lake bottom is buried under younger layers. Water is squeezed out, and the layer becomes 7.2 m of shale (a sedimentary rock made of mud).

      Result: Change in thickness = 12 - 7.2 = 4.8 m. Percent lost = 4.8 ÷ 12 × 100 = 40%. The squeezing comes from gravity: the weight of the layers above.

    • Sedimentary rock to metamorphic rock

      Two plates push together, and the shale is carried down to 10 km below the surface. Use the model in Diagram 2: the surface is 15 °C and the temperature rises 25 °C for each kilometer of depth.

      Result: Temperature = 15 + 25 × 10 = 265 °C, well below the 650 °C at which some rock starts to melt. The pressure is about 2,600 times the air pressure at the surface. Heat and pressure deform the shale into slate (a metamorphic rock) without melting it. Energy: Earth's internal heat.

    • Melting and crystallization

      Rock deep under a volcano melts into magma. Some magma erupts as lava and cools in a few days; some stays 5 km underground and cools over hundreds of thousands of years.

      Result: Fast cooling: crystals have little time to grow, so basalt has crystals under 1 mm. Slow cooling: crystals grow for a long time, so granite has crystals several millimeters across. Energy: internal heat melts the rock; the rock crystallizes as that heat flows away.

    • Uplift brings deep rock back to the surface

      A metamorphic rock formed 10 km underground. Uplift (the slow rise of land, pushed by plate motions) and erosion of the rock above it together bring it up 2 mm each year.

      Result: 10 km = 10,000,000 mm. Time = 10,000,000 ÷ 2 = 5,000,000 years. Once at the surface, the rock can weather into sediment, and the cycle continues.

    After each example, ask: "Which arrow in Diagram 1 is this? Which energy source drives it?" Point out that the arrows go in many directions: any kind of rock can be weathered, deformed or melted, so there is no fixed order around the cycle.

  3. Guided Practice10-15 minutes

    Pairs read the invented observation cards below. They place each sample on the class model and decide which process made it last. They describe the rocks by texture (crystal size, layers, bands, grains) only; no minerals are named.

    Guided practice: invented observation cards for five rock samples
    SampleWhat students see with a hand lens
    AInterlocking crystals 3-8 mm across, no layers
    BRounded grains about 0.5 mm across, glued together in flat layers
    CFlattened crystals lined up in wavy bands; the bands are folded
    DCrystals too small to see; small round holes left by gas bubbles
    EThin flat layers of fine mud with broken shell pieces
    1. Sort the five samples into igneous, sedimentary and metamorphic rock, and write the evidence for each choice.
    2. For each sample, name the last process that formed it and point to its arrow in Diagram 1.
    3. Label each process with its energy source: internal heat, or the sun with gravity.
    4. Choose one sample and draw the next arrow it could follow. Explain why a different arrow is also possible.
  4. Independent Practice10-15 minutes

    Each student models the journey of one sand grain using the invented time line below. They draw the journey as a flow diagram, label each arrow with its process and energy source, and answer: Which stage took the longest? About what percent of the whole journey was it? Which stages were driven mainly by the sun and gravity?

    Independent practice: the invented journey of one sand grain
    StageWhat happensTime (years)
    1Weathering frees the grain from a granite cliff20,000
    2A river carries the grain to the sea3,000
    3The grain settles on the sea floor and is buried by new layers400,000
    4Compaction and cementation turn the layers into sandstone2,000,000
    5Plate motion carries the sandstone deep underground, where heat and pressure change it into metamorphic rock10,000,000

    Students should find a total of 12,423,000 years and see that Stage 5 alone is about 80% of it. Ask them to add one more arrow that would bring the grain back to the surface.

  5. Closure5 minutes

    Students revise their warm-up drawing so that it becomes a cycle with at least one arrow driven by each energy source. Exit ticket: "Name one process in your model driven by Earth's internal heat and one driven by the sun. What would happen to the cycle if Earth's interior cooled completely?"

Differentiation Strategies

For Struggling Students

  • Give a partly filled copy of Diagram 1 with the boxes drawn and the arrow labels in a word bank
  • Use three colors of sticky notes for the energy sources so students sort by color before they write explanations
  • Pair each new word (deposition, compaction, deformation) with a hand motion: sprinkle, press, squeeze

For Advanced Students

  • Ask students to add arrows for shortcuts, such as igneous rock that is deformed directly, and to give an example place for each
  • Have students use Diagram 2 to compare where melting starts if the temperature rises 20 °C or 30 °C per kilometer instead of 25 °C
  • Ask students to write a short critique of a textbook rock cycle picture: what it shows well and what it leaves out

Assessment Guidance

What to Look For

Check that every arrow in a student model names a process, not only a rock type, and that each arrow has an energy source. Look for students who say the sun melts rock underground, or who think rocks must go around the cycle in one order. Listen for evidence statements that use texture ("large crystals, so it cooled slowly") instead of color alone, and check that no one is asked to name minerals.

02

Classroom Activities

3 Activities

1

Clay Rock Cycle Model

25 minGroups of 3-4

Groups use three colors of modeling clay to act out each process in the rock cycle, record what each step stands for and measure how much a layer of "sediment" thins when it is pressed. Nothing is heated: melting is shown with a card and a mixing step, and the group discusses what the model gets wrong.

Procedure

  • Weathering: break a walnut-sized lump of each color into crumbs with your fingers or a plastic knife. This stands for rain, ice and roots breaking rock.
  • Erosion and deposition: carry the crumbs on a sheet of wax paper and sprinkle them in three flat layers, one color at a time. Measure the height of the loose layers with a millimeter ruler.
  • Compaction: cover the layers with wax paper, press them under a stack of books for 2 minutes and measure again. This is your sedimentary rock.
  • Deformation: squeeze the block from both ends with your hands until the layers bend into folds. This is your metamorphic rock.
  • Melting and crystallization: read the Melting card ("Deep underground, rock reaches about 650-1,200 °C and melts"), roll the clay into one ball until the colors mix, and pinch it into new pieces. This is your igneous rock.
  • For each step, put a sticky note on your record sheet with the energy source it stands for. Wash hands after handling clay.

Sample Data (invented)

One group's loose crumb layers were 24 mm high. After pressing under books, the block was 15 mm high, so it thinned by 9 mm, which is 9 ÷ 24 = 37.5% of its height.

Discussion Questions

  • Your layers got 9 mm thinner when pressed. What force does the stack of books stand for, and where does that force come from in the real Earth?
  • Which steps stood for processes driven by Earth's internal heat, and which for processes driven by the sun and gravity?
  • Name two ways this model is not like the real rock cycle (think about time, temperature and what holds real sediment together).

Modification for Distance Learning

Students use bread, crackers or paper scraps at home for the weathering and compaction steps, photograph each stage and post the photos with labels for process and energy source.

2

Crystal Size Detectives

20 minPairs

Pairs use hand lenses and millimeter rulers to compare crystal sizes in a granite sample and a basalt sample, then analyze an invented data table that links cooling time to crystal size. They use the evidence to decide where each rock cooled and add the result to their rock cycle model.

Procedure

  • Measure the longest side of five different crystals in the granite sample and record each length to the nearest millimeter. Find the mean.
  • Try the same with the basalt sample. Record what you see if the crystals are too small to measure.
  • Study the data table below and describe the pattern in one sentence.
  • Do not scratch or break the samples; handle them over a tray.

Sample Data (invented)

Granite crystals: 4, 6, 5, 7 and 3 mm (mean 5 mm). Basalt: crystals too small to measure with a millimeter ruler.

Where the melted rock cooledTime to cool (rounded)Average crystal size
Top surface of a lava flowabout 1 dayunder 0.1 mm
Middle of a thick lava flowabout 5 years0.5 mm
Magma in a crack 500 m undergroundabout 1,000 years2 mm
Large body of magma 6 km undergroundabout 500,000 years8 mm

Discussion Questions

  • Where in the table did the granite sample most likely cool? Use its mean crystal size as evidence.
  • The cooling time grows 500 times from the crack to the large magma body, but the crystal size grows only 4 times. What does that tell you about using crystal size to estimate cooling time?
  • Which energy source melted the rock in the first place, and where did that energy go as the rock cooled?

Challenge Variation

Pairs sketch a graph of crystal size against cooling time and explain why the points would be easier to read if the time axis went up by multiples of 10 instead of equal steps.

3

Rock Cycle Pathway Cards: Build and Critique a Model

20 minGroups of 3-4

Each group gets 12 cards: 5 material cards (magma, igneous rock, sediment, sedimentary rock, metamorphic rock) and 7 process cards (melting, cooling and crystallization, weathering, erosion and transport, deposition, compaction and cementation, deformation by heat and pressure). Groups build a model on chart paper, add an energy sticky note to every process, and then critique a sample student model.

Procedure

  • Lay out the 5 material cards and connect them with the 7 process cards as arrows. A process card may be used for more than one arrow if you draw extra copies.
  • Add a sticky note to each process: yellow for energy from the sun, blue for Earth's internal heat, green for gravity. Some processes get two notes.
  • Find at least two different paths from sediment back to sediment.

Sample Model to Critique

A student drew this model: "Igneous rock → weathering → sediment → compaction → sedimentary rock → melting → magma → cooling → igneous rock. The sun's heat melts the rock underground."

Discussion Questions

  • Which kind of rock is missing from the sample model, and which process card would add it?
  • What is wrong with the energy statement, and how would you rewrite it?
  • The sample model has only one path. Name one arrow your group drew that does not appear in it.

Modification for Distance Learning

Students drag the 12 cards on a shared slide, add colored arrows for the energy sources and record a one-minute voice explanation of one path.

03

Diagrams & Visual Aids

2 diagrams

Diagram 1: A Rock Cycle Model with Its Energy Sources

cooling and crystallization weathering and erosion deposition, compaction and cementation deformation: heat and pressure melting deformation: heat and pressure uplift, then weathering Magma Igneous rock Sediment Sedimentary rock Metamorphic rock Driven by Earth's internal heat Driven by the sun, with gravity
Boxes are forms of Earth material and arrows are processes. Solid arrows are driven by Earth's internal heat; dashed arrows are driven by energy from the sun, with gravity moving and pressing the sediment. The uplift step on the metamorphic-to-sediment arrow is driven by internal heat, and the weathering after it by the sun. Any rock can also melt, so more arrows could point to magma.

Diagram 2: Rock Temperature Rises with Depth (Simplified Model)

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 temperature of the rock (°C) depth below the surface (km) Some rock starts to melt at 650 °C if water is present Model: temperature = 15 °C plus 25 °C for each km of depth Simplified model of continental crust
A simplified model of continental crust, drawn to scale: the surface is 15 °C and the temperature rises 25 °C for each kilometer of depth (many places on the continents measure about 20-30 °C per kilometer near the surface). Some rock starts to melt at about 650 °C when water is present, which in this model happens about 25 km down.

04

Homework Assignment

~30 min

MS-ESS2-1 Homework: Modeling the Rock Cycle and Its Energy

Directions: All data are invented for practice. Draw models with boxes for materials and arrows for processes, and label every arrow with its energy source. Show each calculation with units.

Part 1: Build the Model (Problems 1-2)

  1. A lava flow on an island cools into a dark rock with crystals too small to see. (a) Develop a model (boxes and arrows) that follows this rock's material until it becomes part of a metamorphic rock. Use at least four processes. (b) Label the energy source for every arrow. (c) Write one sentence that explains where Earth's internal heat comes from.
  2. An 8.0 m layer of wet mud is buried and becomes a 5.2 m layer of shale. (a) By how many meters did the layer thin? (b) What percent of its thickness did it lose? (c) Which force squeezed the mud, and what supplied it?

Part 2: Energy in the Cycle (Problems 3-4)

  1. In one region the surface rock is 20 °C and the temperature rises 30 °C for each kilometer of depth. (a) What is the temperature 10 km down? (b) At what depth does the rock reach 650 °C, where some rock begins to melt if water is present? (c) Which energy source makes the rock hotter with depth?
  2. A metamorphic rock that formed 18 km underground is now exposed in a mountain. (a) If uplift and erosion together brought it up 1.5 mm each year, how long did the trip take? (b) Which part of the trip was driven by Earth's internal heat, and which by the sun and gravity?

Part 3: Analyze Data and Critique Models (Problems 5-6)

  1. Invented crystal lengths (mm) for three igneous rocks: Rock P: 0.2, 0.3, 0.2, 0.4, 0.4. Rock Q: 6, 8, 7, 9, 5. Rock R: 2, 3, 2.5, 3.5, 2. (a) Find the mean crystal length of each rock. (b) Rank the rocks from shortest to longest cooling time. (c) Which rock most likely cooled deepest underground? Explain with the data.
  2. A classmate writes: "Rocks always go igneous → sedimentary → metamorphic → igneous, in that order. The sun's heat melts rock deep underground." (a) Identify two errors. (b) Draw a corrected model that includes at least two paths the classmate left out. (c) Explain what drives melting instead.

Rubric

CriterionFull Credit (2 pts)Partial Credit (1 pt)
ModelBoxes for materials, arrows for processes, and more than one path; matches the rocks in the problemModel has boxes and arrows but one path only or a missing process
Energy SourcesEvery arrow is labeled with internal heat, or the sun with gravity, and the labels are correctSome arrows labeled, or one energy source wrong
Data and CalculationsMeans, percents, temperatures and times correct with units, and used as evidenceCorrect method with one calculation or unit error
CritiqueNames specific errors, explains why they are wrong and gives a corrected versionNames an error without a correction

05

Quiz: 20 Questions

Interactive, with answers

Instructions

All data are invented for practice. Use the rock cycle model and Diagram 2 where they help. Your score updates as you answer, and Reset quiz clears everything so you or your students can try again.

Multiple choice: pick an option to check it. Short answer: write your answer, then reveal the model answer.

0 of 20 answered · 0 correct

  1. Question 1 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    Deep underground, rock melts into magma. Which energy source drives this melting?

  2. Question 2 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    Which process turns loose sediment into solid sedimentary rock?

  3. Question 3 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    A granite sample has interlocking crystals 5-10 mm across. What does this evidence suggest about how it formed?

  4. Question 4 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    Use the model: the surface is 15 °C and the temperature rises 25 °C for each kilometer of depth. What is the temperature 12 km down?

  5. Question 5 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    Rain, ice and wind break down rock and carry the pieces away. Which energy source mainly drives these processes?

  6. Question 6 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    What happens to a rock during deformation?

  7. Question 7 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    A model shows only one arrow leaving sedimentary rock: "sedimentary rock → metamorphic rock." Which arrow would make the model more accurate?

  8. Question 8 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    Invented data: a 10 m layer of mud is buried and becomes 7 m of shale. What percent of its thickness did it lose?

  9. Question 9 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    Where does most of Earth's internal heat come from?

  10. Question 10 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    A dark rock has crystals too small to see and many small round holes left by gas bubbles. Where did it most likely form?

  11. Question 11 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    Invented data, average crystal size of four igneous rocks: W, too small to see; X, 0.5 mm; Y, 9 mm; Z, 3 mm. Which rock most likely took the longest to cool?

  12. Question 12 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    Which statement about the rock cycle is accurate?

  13. Question 13 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    Uplift and erosion together bring a buried rock up 2 mm each year. How long does it take to rise from 8 km down to the surface?

  14. Question 14 of 20 · Multiple Choice

    In the rock cycle model, what happens to the amount of rock material over time?

  15. Question 15 of 20 · Short Answer

    Trace a path that turns sandstone into igneous rock. Name each process and the energy source that drives it.

  16. Question 16 of 20 · Short Answer

    In one region the surface is 10 °C and the temperature rises 20 °C for each kilometer of depth. How deep is the rock when it reaches 650 °C?

  17. Question 17 of 20 · Short Answer

    In a clay model of the rock cycle, students press crumbs under books and then squeeze the block into folds. Give one way the model is like the real rock cycle and one way it is not.

  18. Question 18 of 20 · Short Answer

    Invented data: a pebble is weathered out of a cliff (5,000 years), carried by a river (1,000 years), buried and cemented into rock (3,000,000 years) and then deformed deep underground (6,000,000 years). Find the total time and the percent of it spent in the stage driven by Earth's internal heat.

  19. Question 19 of 20 · Short Answer

    Explain why the rock cycle needs both Earth's internal heat and energy from the sun. What would stop if each one disappeared?

  20. Question 20 of 20 · Short Answer

    A rock in a mountain has flattened crystals lined up in wavy, folded bands. Explain how it formed and what energy drove the change.

0 of 20 answered · 0 correct

06

Frequently Asked Questions

10 Questions

What does MS-ESS2-1 mean?

MS-ESS2-1 asks middle school students to develop a model of the rock cycle that shows how Earth's materials change form and what energy drives those changes. The code means Middle School, Earth and Space Science, core idea 2 (Earth's Systems), performance expectation 1.

Is MS-ESS2-1 taught in grade 6, 7 or 8?

It depends on the school. MS-ESS2-1 is a middle school standard for grades 6-8, and it often sits in an Earth science unit with MS-ESS2-2 (surface processes) and MS-ESS2-3 (plate motions). In some integrated courses it is taught next to MS-PS1-4, because melting and crystallization are changes of state.

What energy drives the rock cycle?

Two sources do: Earth's internal heat and energy from the sun. Internal heat, from the planet's formation and from radioactive elements, drives melting, deformation and uplift. The sun drives the wind, rain and ice that weather and carry rock, and gravity pulls sediment downhill and presses buried layers together.

What is the assessment boundary for MS-ESS2-1?

The official Assessment Boundary says assessment does not include the identification and naming of minerals. Students can describe crystal size, layers and bands, and they can name rock types, but quizzes should not ask them to identify specific minerals.

Do rocks go around the rock cycle in a fixed order?

No. Any kind of rock can be weathered into sediment, deformed into metamorphic rock or melted into magma. A rock can skip steps or repeat one many times, so a good model has arrows in several directions, not a single circle.

How long does the rock cycle take?

Most paths take millions of years, but single steps vary widely. Lava can cool into rock in days, a landslide moves sediment in minutes, and burial, deformation and uplift take millions of years. That is why students use models and data instead of watching one rock go around the cycle.

Can students melt crayons to model the rock cycle?

Students should not heat wax or crayons. This lesson uses modeling clay with no heat, and melting is shown with a card and a mixing step. If a teacher wants to show real melting and cooling, it should be a teacher-only demonstration with the teacher in control of the heat source, or a video.

What is the difference between weathering and erosion?

Weathering breaks rock into smaller pieces where it sits; erosion picks up those pieces and carries them away. Freezing water cracking a boulder is weathering, and a river carrying the broken pieces downstream is erosion. Both are driven mainly by the sun, with gravity.

How does MS-ESS2-1 connect to the water cycle?

The water cycle (MS-ESS2-4) is one of the engines of the rock cycle. Sun-driven evaporation leads to rain and snow, which weather rock, and rivers and glaciers carry the sediment. Water also carries dissolved material that cements sediment into rock.

What comes after MS-ESS2-1 in high school?

HS-ESS2-3 asks students to model Earth's interior and the cycling of matter by mantle convection, which explains where the internal heat goes. HS-ESS2-1 asks how internal and surface processes build and wear down landforms at different scales. Both build on the rock cycle model from MS-ESS2-1.